Source: Pioneer Press, By Tad Vezner
Article Last Updated: 09/26/2008 10:17:11 PM CDT
With his 6-year-old daughter and two other girls playing in the room behind him, a St. Paul man threw his ex-girlfriend’s dog from her third-story balcony, injuring it so badly it had to be put to sleep, according to police.
On Friday, police charged Donald Dornseif, 44, with felony animal cruelty.
A pair of neighbors who had been standing on the balcony below said they saw 3-year-old “Precious” plummet to the ground outside an apartment complex in St. Paul’s Payne-Phalen neighborhood, where she moaned until authorities arrived about 10 p.m. Thursday.
Cynthia Hayes — whose 5-year-old daughter was in the apartment with Dornseif — was standing below him when she said she heard him say “I hate animals.”
“I told him, ‘You hate animals because you are an animal,’ ” Hayes yelled up.
“Do you want to see the dog hit the sidewalk?” Dornseif allegedly replied.
Seconds later, “the dog came out flying,” said Debbie Bailey, who had been standing beside Hayes. She didn’t see Dornseif throw Precious, a stout English bulldog. But Hayes said her daughter did; the young girl described to police how Dornseif propelled the dog with both arms.
Two-year-old Elizabeth Mabry — who was being watched by Hayes and Bailey — later described what she saw to her mother, Andrea Mabry, who also lives in the building.
“Doggie went boom,” the girl said, throwing her arms wide.
Dornseif’s ex-girlfriend, Sara Goff, said she got a call from Bailey after the three girls — her daughter, Mya Dornseif-Goff, 6; Hayes’ daughter, Cameryn Hodges, 5, and another 10-year-old girl from the building — ran frantically down to Bailey’s apartment.
“I said, ‘What did you do to my dog?’ He said, ‘I didn’t do nothing to her. She jumped,’ ” Goff said.
Goff, 25, said Dornseif had “popped by,” and she left the apartment to go to the store. She and her daughter had received the dog as a gift from a new boyfriend, and she claimed Dornseif never warmed to it because of that. She and Dornseif had split several years ago, but their daughter lived with her full time.
Dornseif told police he hadn’t talked to the neighbors, though he had been drinking, according to a criminal complaint. He said he bent to pick the dog up, but “before he could even get it up right, the dog jumped out of his arms, over the railing.”
But police said it was impossible for the short, 60- to 70-pound dog — which fell 20 to 25 feet down and a full 8 to 10 feet out from the balcony — to have jumped that far out without being thrown. The balcony has a 4-foot railing that the dog cannot squeeze through.
Precious broke her leg and neck and suffered other internal injuries. She was later euthanized.
“This morning my daughter still insisted the dog’s in the hospital,” Hayes added. “I had to tell her that the dog’s in heaven now.”
Officers searched for Dornseif after he left the complex in the 1300 block of Mississippi Street. They were called about an hour later to his current girlfriend’s home in the 1100 block of McLean Ave. The current girlfriend didn’t know about the dog but called police about a separate argument they were having, according to police spokesman Peter Panos.
As for young Mya, her mother found her that night curled up and asleep in the corner where Precious usually rests.
“I don’t think Mya actually wants to believe her dad did that,” Bailey said.