Source: WacoTrib.com, May 7, 2009
Thursday, May 07, 2009
The 78 dogs taken from what have been described as cramped, foul conditions at an alleged puppy mill in Elm Mott are suffering from health, behavioral and emotional issues, said Karen Froehlich, director of the Waco Humane Society.
Some face the backs of their cages and won’t turn to look at the staff, who have been caring for them since they were taken in a raid Friday on a home at 1209 Oak Knoll Lane. Others are so poorly behaved, the staff haven’t even been able to get close enough to bathe them. And still others spend countless hours just pacing in their new cages.
“These dogs have not been cared for in a loving home,” Froehlich said.
As of Wednesday, no arrests had been made in connection with the alleged puppy mill, said Randy Plemons, chief deputy with the McLennan County Sheriff’s Office. A custody hearing will be held at 9:30 a.m. Friday in Justice of the Peace Kristi DeCluitt’s court.
A warrant filed Friday in district court refers to an investigation of allegations of animal cruelty by the owners of the house in which the dogs were taken, James Van Winkle, 66, and his wife, Barbara Mitchell, 58. Reached at their Elm Mott home Monday, Mitchell said the couple had hired several caretakers to look after the dogs because both she and her husband were unable to take care of the animals because of health problems.
Mitchell said she and her husband had placed an ad on Craigslist.org two days before the raid asking for someone to take the dogs.
Reached on his cell phone Wednesday, Van Winkle referred all questions to the couple’s lawyer, whom he said they hired Tuesday. The lawyer, Tom Ragland, declined to comment.
The couple had at least 150 dogs on their property, most of which were Great Pyrenees, rat terriers and Cavalier King Charles Spaniels. Of those, 78 — including about a dozen rat terrier puppies — were deemed most in need of removal from the conditions, which Plemons described as “deplorable” and one of the worst cases of animal cruelty the county has seen.
Plemons said up to five dogs were kept in cages meant for rabbits. In the cages, feces accumulated up to 6 inches high. Nearby was wet, moldy food.
A rat terrier and a puppy huddle up Wednesday in an area of the Waco Humane Society. Both were taken Friday by McLennan County sheriff’s officials from their Elm Mott home. (Duane A. Laverty photo)
Deputies also found a 55-gallon barrel full of dead dogs and another full of dead goats. Also on the property was a dirt mound with goat legs sticking out the top.
State Rep. Charles “Doc” Anderson, R-Waco, said he spent part of his day Wednesday speaking with Rep. Senfronia Thompson, D-Houston, who wrote a bill that would require breeders with more than 11 unneutered female animals to submit to licensing, annual inspections, background checks and penalties as high as $5,000 per animal for violations.
“We need to go after the bad actors,” said Anderson, who is a veterinarian. “But we need to craft the bill so we don’t put good folks out of business.
“It’s important to have good legislation. That’s a terrible situation out there (in Elm Mott). Terrible. These folks say they had health problems and couldn’t care for the pets, but that doesn’t justify that kind of extreme neglect.”
The bill has not yet made it to the House floor for discussion and a vote.
Karomy Harmel, president of the Central Texas chapter of the Texas Humane Legislation Network, said the bill, written as is, will not hurt breeders.
“These are just minimum care standards,” Harmel said. “Clean water. An appropriate amount of food. Minimum standards that should be common sense to any breeder.
“And it also protects the consumers. Because if the consumers aren’t happy with the dogs, they end up in our local shelters, where it’s the taxpayers’ job to take care of them.”
Kim Johnson, a local dog breeder, said she is opposed to the bill because animal cruelty is already against the law.
“I’m just not for big government,” she said. “There are states I won’t even ship to because they require microchipping, and I’m against it. It’s like, ‘Leave us alone.’ ”
Carrie Kuehl, director of Waco’s Animal Birth Control Clinic, said clinics like hers are set up to prevent these sorts of cases of alleged animal cruelty.
“It can be frustrating to see irresponsible breeding of any degree while the area animal organizations work so hard to proactively improve the animals’ lives in our community,” Kuehl said. “Every litter or, in the case of puppy mills, multiple litters reduce the good community effects of responsible owners spaying and neutering their pets.”
Until DeCluitt decides custody, the dogs are being kept at the Waco Humane Society. Froehlich said she has been consulting with rescue groups statewide that specialize in treating animals taken from such conditions.
“Every dog needs a chance,” she said. “There have been small improvements since Friday. Some would not even pick up their heads, and now they’re coming to the gates. They’re learning to trust people.
“Emotionally, this has been very difficult on the staff here. We are in this business because we love animals. We’re doing everything we can.”